Skip to content

Independent rankingsNo paid placement

Bedside PicksBedside Picks home, bedsidepicks.com

XL toys

Vixen Mustang vs Tantus Silk

Tantus Silk Medium leads our vixen mustang ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.

Reviewed by · Prices checked · How we rank

The verdict

Start with Vixen Mustang. VixSkin feels startlingly like skin, firm inside and soft outside, and it warms up fast in your hands.

Quick picks

  1. Best overallNo. 1 ↓

    Vixen Mustang

    $125.75 at SheVibe · ships free

  2. Runner-upNo. 2 ↓

    Tantus Silk Medium

    $42 at SheVibe

  3. Budget pickNo. 4 ↓

    Tantus Silk Small

    $31.99 at SheVibe

At a glance

Compare the top 5

  1. 1Vixen MustangVixen Mustang$125.75from 16 reviews$125.75 →
  2. 2Tantus Silk MediumTantus Silk Medium$42Too new to rate$42 →
  3. 3Vixen MaverickVixen Maverick$129.50from 10 reviews$129.50 →
  4. 4Tantus Silk SmallTantus Silk Small$31.99Too new to rate$31.99 →
  5. 5Tantus EchoTantus Echo$51.99Too new to rate$51.99 →

The ranking

The full ranking

Ranked by demand, review quality, availability, and fit. Stars are owner review averages from the store or brand site, where there are enough reviews.

How we rank
Vixen Mustang VixSkin realistic dildo in chocolate, on white.
Vixen Mustang VixSkin realistic dildo in chocolate, on white.
No. 1

No. 1 · Vixen Creations

Vixen Mustang

from 16 reviews$125.75

VixSkin dual-density with a flared base. Soft skin, firm core. The realistic dildo people drop into a Joque or Breathable ring when Maverick was the wrong silhouette.

Cons

  • Read the size chart. Names are not a scale
  • Water-based lube. Harness not included

Why it ranks: Shape search next to Maverick. Reviews compare the two. Harness-compatible and still sold.

$125.75 at SheVibeships free

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Official Tantus Silk photo used for Silk Medium, a harness-compatible platinum silicone dildo.
Official Tantus Silk photo used for Silk Medium, a harness-compatible platinum silicone dildo.
No. 2

No. 2 · Tantus

Tantus Silk Medium

Too new to rate$42

The middle Silk. About 5.5 by 1 inch. Smooth. Flared base. The step up when Small starts to feel like a finger.

Pros

  • Platinum-cure silicone

Cons

  • Water-based lube
  • Still smooth. If you wanted texture, that's a different toy

Why it ranks: Medium is the Silk people stay on. Tantus still sells it.

$42 at SheVibe

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Official Vixen Maverick in vanilla. Dual-density silicone insertable on white.
Official Vixen Maverick in vanilla. Dual-density silicone insertable on white.
No. 3

No. 3 · Vixen Creations

Vixen Maverick

from 10 reviews$129.50

Dual-density platinum silicone. Soft skin over a firmer core. Flared base. The dildo if you want squish, not a broomstick, in a harness.

Cons

  • Water-based lube. Silicone lube can damage silicone
  • Heavier than a Silk. That's the skin

Why it ranks: Dual-density search is real. Reviews get specific about the skin. Vixen still sells Maverick in the US.

$129.50 at SheVibeships free

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Official Tantus Silk Small. Slim platinum silicone insertables with flared bases on white.
Official Tantus Silk Small. Slim platinum silicone insertables with flared bases on white.
No. 4

No. 4 · Tantus

Tantus Silk Small

Too new to rate$31.99

Named platinum silicone. About 4.25 inches, 0.8 across. Flared base. Harness compatible. The first dildo if the kit still feels like a guess.

Pros

  • Platinum-cure silicone

Cons

  • Water-based lube only
  • Slim. That's the point

Why it ranks: Harness lists need a real dildo SKU. Tantus prints the formula and the size.

$31.99 at SheVibe

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Tantus Echo by Tantus.
Tantus Echo by Tantus.
No. 5

No. 5 · Tantus

Tantus Echo

Too new to rate$51.99

Shorter curved Tantus. Platinum. A silicone dildo if you want a bump, not length.

Pros

  • Platinum-cure silicone
  • Flared base

Cons

  • Texture. If you wanted smooth, that's Silk
  • Confirm whether your listing includes the bullet

Why it ranks: Curve search is quieter than Silk. Official page is live.

$51.99 at SheVibe

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)

Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)

Close behind is Tantus Silk Medium. A smooth, medium dildo with a gentle taper. Easy to love, easy to harness. Vixen Maverick is the wildcard, and a good one.

Solo, stick it to the shower wall or take your time on your back with a lot of lube. Both are great. Use it while they go down on you. Full and licked at the same time is a very good combination.

Before you buy

Buying guide

Harness behavior

Both work with Joque and Sportsheets. Match O-ring size.

No. 1 · Vixen Mustang

$125.75at SheVibeships free

FAQ

Common questions

Which for beginners?
Silk Small or Medium. Mustang once you know you like the size.
Cleanup?
Both: warm water, gentle soap, toy cleaner.
How did you rank these?
Mostly by how people talk about a toy after they've actually lived with it for a while. Stock and how well it fits this exact list count too, and we re-check every week.

Also on the shelf

Related lists

Sex toys on sale now · 11 markdowns up to 48% off, prices checked Oct 19