Skip to content

No paid placement

Bedside PicksBedside Picks home, bedsidepicks.com

Just you

Best silicone butt plugs

b-Vibe Snug Plug 2 leads our silicone butt plugs ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.

Reviewed by · Prices checked · How we rank

The verdict

A silicone butt plug has to name the formula and keep a base outside. Ten still sold in the US. Snug 1 if you want small weight. Bootie if you want curve. Ryder if you want firm platinum.

Our No. 1: b-Vibe Snug Plug 2

Quick picks

  1. Best overallNo. 1 ↓

    b-Vibe Snug Plug 2

    Shop $48 at SheVibe

  2. Runner-upNo. 2 ↓

    b-Vibe Snug Plug 1

    Shop $45 at SheVibe

  3. Budget pickNo. 6 ↓

    Tantus Silk Small

    Shop $31.99 at SheVibe

At a glance

Compare the top 6

  1. 1b-Vibe Snug Plug 2b-Vibe Snug Plug 2$48Too new to rate$48 →
  2. 2b-Vibe Snug Plug 1b-Vibe Snug Plug 1$45Too new to rate$45 →
  3. 3Tantus RyderTantus Ryder$32Too new to rate$32 →
  4. 4b-Vibe Novice Plugb-Vibe Novice Plug$110 to $123.95Too new to rate$110 →
  5. 5njoy Pure Plugnjoy Pure Plug$85Too new to rate$85 →
  6. 6Tantus Silk SmallTantus Silk Small$31.99Too new to rate$31.99 →

The ranking

The full ranking

Ranked by demand, review quality, availability, and fit. Stars are owner review averages from the store or brand site, where there are enough reviews.

How we rank

No. 1 · b-VibePhoto at the top ↑

b-Vibe Snug Plug 2

Too new to rate$48
Shop $48 at SheVibe

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

The Snug people stay on. About 1.2 across. Around 112 grams. Same thin neck. Same T-base. Step up after 1 felt easy.

Pros

  • Body-safe silicone

Cons

  • Weight is the product. If you wanted a motor, that's Ditto+ or Plug-ilicious
  • Start at 1 if 2 looks like a dare

Why it ranks: Weighted silicone search names 2.

b-Vibe Snug Plug 1 by b-Vibe.
b-Vibe Snug Plug 1 by b-Vibe.
No. 2

No. 2 · b-Vibe

b-Vibe Snug Plug 1

Too new to rate$45
Shop $45 at SheVibe

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Small weighted silicone. Named. Finger-sized. T-base. The first silicone plug if you want mass and a polymer you can say out loud.

Pros

  • Body-safe silicone

Cons

  • Small. You may outgrow it in a month
  • Still a plug. Lube. Flared base. Don't skip either

Why it ranks: Silicone-plug search that wants a starter size lands on Snug 1.

Tantus Ryder by Tantus.
Tantus Ryder by Tantus.
No. 3

No. 3 · Tantus

Tantus Ryder

Too new to rate$32
Shop $32 at SheVibe

Free shipping at SheVibe over $68. Tempted to treat yourself? Add a silky lube and it all ships free.

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Platinum-cure. Flared base. Firmer than b-Vibe. No pellets. The Tantus plug if you already trust their formula.

Cons

  • Firmer than b-Vibe. That's the silicone, not a defect
  • Water-based lube

Why it ranks: Platinum-plug search is picky. Official page is live.

b-Vibe Novice Plug by b-Vibe.
b-Vibe Novice Plug by b-Vibe.
No. 4

No. 4 · b-Vibe

b-Vibe Novice Plug

Too new to rate$110 to $123.95
Shop $110 at SheVibelower price · ships freeShop $123.95 at Pleasure Chestships free

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Small vibrating first plug. Soft silicone. The name is the pitch. Angle still matters more than the buzz.

Pros

  • Body-safe silicone
  • Rechargeable motor

Cons

  • Beginner size. The motor will not save a bad angle
  • If you wanted weight and no buzz, that's Snug 1

Why it ranks: Novice search is first-plug plus buzz.

Official njoy Pure Plug product photo. Stainless plug family on a wide studio background.
Official njoy Pure Plug product photo. Stainless plug family on a wide studio background.
No. 5

No. 5 · njoy

njoy Pure Plug

Too new to rate$85
Shop $85 at SheVibeships freeShop $85 at Pleasure Chestships free

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Steel, not silicone. On the list so hard-plug search does not buy the wrong aisle. Weight without give.

Pros

  • Body-safe stainless steel
  • Flared base

Cons

  • Hard. Lube. Slow
  • If the neck is too thin for you, it will not stay. That's a size problem, not a night problem

Why it ranks: Silicone-plug search leaks into njoy. See Best stainless steel sex toys.

Official Tantus Silk Small. Slim platinum silicone with a flared base on white.
Official Tantus Silk Small. Slim platinum silicone with a flared base on white.
No. 6

No. 6 · Tantus

Tantus Silk Small

Too new to rate$31.99
Shop $31.99 at SheVibe

Free shipping at SheVibe over $68. Tempted to treat yourself? Add a silky lube and it all ships free.

Ships discreetly from SheVibe

Slim platinum shaft with a flared base. Not a classic bulb. People still start here because the formula is printed.

Pros

  • Platinum-cure silicone

Cons

  • This is a slim dildo shape. Don't expect a neck that cinches
  • Water-based lube

Why it ranks: Silicone-plug search sometimes wanted a slim dildo. Fit is adjacent.

Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)

Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)

First anal night: Best beginner anal toys. Mass as the job: Best weighted butt plugs. Motor: Best vibrating butt plugs. Full shelf: Best butt plugs. The bottle: Best anal lube.

Before you buy

Buying guide

Weight, curve, or a set

Snug has pellets. Bootie is shape. Booty Call is three cheap sizes. Ryder is firm platinum. Pick the stay.

Motor later

Ditto+ and Novice add buzz. Silent first if this is night one. Water-based on silicone.

More specific lists

FAQ

Common questions

What is the best silicone butt plug?
Snug 1 for a named small weighted plug. Bootie for curve and no pellets. Ryder for firmer platinum. Lube first.
Silicone plug or weighted plug?
This list is the polymer. Best weighted butt plugs is mass as the job. Snug sits on both because the weight lives inside silicone.
Do silicone butt plugs need a flared base?
Yes. A retrieval neck you can name. If the base can slip in, it is not a plug.
What lube for a silicone plug?
Water-based. Sassy if you want gel. Silicone lube can wreck silicone toys. Best anal lube is the bottle list.

Also on the shelf

Related lists

Sex toys on sale now · 8 markdowns up to 48% off, prices checked Oct 24