First times · 2026-09-11
How to choose a butt plug
Flared base. Start small. Named silicone. Then lube.
Start here
The first three
Names first. Shop this pick opens the store page. The cards below still have the catch.
No. 1 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Snug Plug 2
The next Snug. About 1.2 across. Around 112 grams. Buy it after 1 stays, not because a photo looked modest.
Read the cardA butt plug is a flare you keep outside and a size you can say out loud. That is the how-to.
Most first-plug mistakes are the same. No flare. A jelly teardrop. Jumping a size because steel looked pretty. A dry night. This page is the lecture. The ranked shelf under it is what I would actually put in a how-to cart.
If you already know the toy, skip ahead. Best butt plugs is the finished ranking. First anal: Best beginner anal toys. Weighted: Best weighted butt plugs. Vibrating: Best vibrating butt plugs. How to use lube is the bottle lecture.
Before you buy
How to choose
Flare, or walk away
A retrieval base stays outside. Jelly teardrops do not count. If the listing will not show the flare, skip it.
Smaller than the photo
Snug 1 is a finger. Booty Call is a set. Snug 2 is a later night. Don't buy steel because it photographed well.
Motor optional
A still plug teaches size. Novice or Ditto if you already want buzz. Best vibrating butt plugs is that aisle.
The bottle
Thick water-based. Same checkout. Dry is how people decide plugs were a mistake.
Read this first
The usual mistakes
Don't start in steel
njoy is a later argument. Hard does not forgive a size guess. Silicone first.
Don't skip the flare
A handle or a T-base is the product. Beads are a different list.
Don't bag it wet
Soap. Dry time. Then a named bag if you want one.
Named plugs to start from
The full list. Refreshed weekly. Review quality on each card.
No. 1 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Snug Plug 2
The next Snug. About 1.2 across. Around 112 grams. Buy it after 1 stays, not because a photo looked modest.
Review quality 8.2
No. 2 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Snug Plug 1
Finger-sized weighted plug. About 0.9 across. Thin neck. T-base. The first named plug if a training set looks like homework.
Review quality 7.9
No. 3 · Fun Factory
Fun Factory Bootie
Curved silicone. Flexible base. No pellets unless you buy the Vibe. The first plug if you want shape, not shot weight.
Review quality 8.0
No. 4 · njoy
njoy Pure Plug
Stainless. Weighted. A neck that keeps it. Hard. Lube. Slow. Not a first how-to if silicone still feels new.
Review quality 8.6
No. 5 · We-Vibe
We-Vibe Ditto+
Small vibrating plug. Remote in the box. App if you want it. About two and a half inches in. Not a fill toy.
Review quality 7.8
No. 6 · Satisfyer
Satisfyer Booty Call
Three silicone plugs. Three shapes. Retrieval rings. The cheap training set if you want to learn a size before you spend.
Review quality 6.8
No. 7 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Novice Plug
Small vibrating first plug. Soft silicone. A how-to pick only if you already want a motor on night one.
Review quality 7.4
No. 8 · Tantus
Tantus Ryder
Platinum bulb. Flared base. Firmer than Bootie. A how-to plug if you wanted named silicone and no motor.
Review quality 8.1
Leave it · Marketplace teardrop
Mystery jelly butt plug
Unlabeled jelly teardrop. Soft until it smells. No named polymer. Throw it out. Buy Snug 1 or Bootie.
Fails the floor
Don't buy this.
No. 1 is still b-Vibe Snug Plug 2. Opens the store page.
FAQ
Common questions
- How do I choose a butt plug?
- Flared base. Named silicone or steel. Start smaller than the photo. Snug Plug 1 if you want a named small. Bootie if you want curve, not pellets. Booty Call if you want a cheap set.
- What size butt plug should a beginner buy?
- Finger-sized. Snug 1 or Bootie. Jumping to steel because it looked pretty is how people quit. Best beginner anal toys is the kinder list.
- Do I need a vibrating plug?
- No. A motor is extra homework. Ditto+ or Novice if you already want buzz. How-to is the flare and the size.
- What lube with a butt plug?
- Thick water-based. Sassy. Reapply. Best anal lube names the bottles. How to use lube is the lecture.
Also on the shelf