First times
How to choose a butt plug
b-Vibe Snug Plug 2 leads our choose a butt plug ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.
Reviewed by Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer) · Prices checked · How we rank
The verdict
Anal toys reward patience. Go slow, use a lot of lube and let your body say when it's ready for more.
Our No. 1: b-Vibe Snug Plug 2
Quick picks
At a glance
Compare the top 5
The ranking
Named plugs to start from
Ranked by demand, review quality, availability, and fit. Stars are owner review averages from the store or brand site, where there are enough reviews.
No. 1 · b-VibePhoto at the top ↑
b-Vibe Snug Plug 2
Ships discreetly from SheVibe
The next Snug. About 1.2 across. Around 112 grams. Buy it after 1 stays, not because a photo looked modest.
Pros
- Body-safe silicone
Cons
- Weight is the product. If you wanted a motor, that's Ditto+ or Plug-ilicious
- Start at 1 if 2 looks like a dare
Why it ranks: How-to needs the step-up in writing.
No. 2 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Snug Plug 1
Ships discreetly from SheVibe
Finger-sized weighted plug. About 0.9 across. Thin neck. T-base. The first named plug if a training set looks like homework.
Pros
- Body-safe silicone
Cons
- Small. You may outgrow it in a month
- Still a plug. Lube. Flared base. Don't skip either
Why it ranks: How-to-choose-a-plug search wants a small named start.
No. 3 · njoy
njoy Pure Plug
Ships discreetly from SheVibe
Stainless. Weighted. A neck that keeps it. Hard. Lube. Slow. Not a first how-to if silicone still feels new.
Pros
- Body-safe stainless steel
- Flared base
Cons
- Hard. Lube. Slow
- If the neck is too thin for you, it will not stay. That's a size problem, not a night problem
Why it ranks: Steel-plug how-to is a later chapter.
No. 4 · b-Vibe
b-Vibe Novice Plug
Ships discreetly from SheVibe
Small vibrating first plug. Soft silicone. A how-to pick only if you already want a motor on night one.
Pros
- Body-safe silicone
- Rechargeable motor
Cons
- Beginner size. The motor will not save a bad angle
- If you wanted weight and no buzz, that's Snug 1
Why it ranks: Novice search is first-plug plus buzz.
No. 5 · Tantus
Tantus Ryder
Free shipping at SheVibe over $68. Tempted to treat yourself? Add a silky lube and it all ships free.
Ships discreetly from SheVibe
Platinum bulb. Flared base. Firmer than Bootie. A how-to plug if you wanted named silicone and no motor.
Pros
- Platinum-cure silicone
Cons
- Firmer than b-Vibe. That's the silicone, not a defect
- Water-based lube
Why it ranks: People who already buy Tantus look this up.
Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)
Notes from Bedside CSO (Chief Sex Officer)
Lube the toy and yourself, breathe out as it goes in, and go slow. Thick water-based lube is your best friend. Alone, wear it for a while before you even start touching yourself. Anticipation does a lot.
Our favorite to learn on is b-Vibe Snug Plug 2. A little bigger and heavier than the first size. That snug, full feeling gets louder.
For exact widths and insertable lengths, see our butt plug size guide. Wondering whether you want a plug at all? Read prostate massager vs butt plug.
Before you buy
Buying guide
Flare, or walk away
A retrieval base stays outside. Jelly teardrops do not count. If the listing will not show the flare, skip it.
Smaller than the photo
Snug 1 is a finger. Booty Call is a set. Snug 2 is a later night. Don't buy steel because it photographed well.
Motor optional
A still plug teaches size. Novice or Ditto if you already want buzz. Best vibrating butt plugs is that aisle.
The bottle
Thick water-based. Same checkout. Dry is how people decide plugs were a mistake.
Read this first
Mistakes to avoid
Don't start in steel
njoy is a later argument. Hard does not forgive a size guess. Silicone first.
Don't skip the flare
A handle or a T-base is the product. Beads are a different list.
Don't bag it wet
Soap. Dry time. Then a named bag if you want one.
FAQ
Common questions
- How do I choose a butt plug?
- Flared base. Named silicone or steel. Start smaller than the photo. Snug Plug 1 if you want a named small. Bootie if you want curve, not pellets. Booty Call if you want a cheap set.
- What size butt plug should a beginner buy?
- Finger-sized. Snug 1 or Bootie. Jumping to steel because it looked pretty is how people quit. Best beginner anal toys is the kinder list.
- Do I need a vibrating plug?
- No. A motor is extra homework. Ditto+ or Novice if you already want buzz. How-to is the flare and the size.
- What lube with a butt plug?
- Thick water-based. Sassy. Reapply. Best anal lube names the bottles.
Also on the shelf
Related lists
Best butt plugsb-Vibe Snug Plug 2 leads our butt plugs ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.
Best beginner anal toysb-Vibe Snug Plug 1 leads our beginner anal toys ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.
Best anal lubeSliquid Sassy leads our anal lube ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.
How to use lubeSliquid H2O leads our use lube ranking. Real products still sold in the US, re-checked weekly.
Sex toys on sale now · 8 markdowns up to 48% off, prices checked Oct 26